Hope everyone had a good holiday season
On a whim I decided to watch the anime Sword Art Online and for the most part I was if nothing else entertained. The premise of a newly launched MMO has trapped its players in it and if they die then they die in real life is highly reminiscent of .hack and the Matrix; although in comparison to those two this show is very straightforward. The players are trapped, they know how to get out, try to get out but are human so have human problems along the way. While I found the series to be entertaining and do reccomend it for some light fun I also had some problems with it. So let’s take a look at the series in more detail. Beware of Spoilers ye who read on
It could’ve been longer: while SA:O has plenty of good ideas the author doesn’t spend much time developing them and using them to their full potential. By extension this creates a similar problem in regards to recurring characters in that they could have easily been given more development. You can always make the argument that this a good thing since it didn’t get drawn out, but that doesn’t mean what we have is totally satisfactory either. Considering that its called Sword Art Online staying with that game wouldn’t have been a problem.
The female characters: On one hand, I can’t really see anyone watching this past about episode 10 if they don’t care about the Kirito/Asuna relationship, so the female characters are kinda unavoidable. On the other hand, if the female characters weren’t by and large damsels in distress, and more dynamic it could only be an improvement.
You forgot to give the villain a motive: Some kind of reason for why Kayaba did what he did would’ve been nice compared to “I forgot and some kind of wish fulfillment” well the latter was only bad cause its tacked on.
While all three of the above problems are present in the show from the beginning, they all get much worse with the second arc. The first arc ended for the second,most of the characters are forgotten until the epilogue, Asuna is reduced to a damsel in distress, and the villain is somewhat all over the place. Also the first arc didn’t have things like “incest” that’s not really incest cause they aren’t related and attempted tentacle rape; or the kind of stuff that just makes anime painful for me to watch now. Despite that fact the second arc isn’t terrible, what the story is trying to do isn’t necessarily a bad idea, it just lacks enough time to do it well.
Of course the show has its good parts: the relationship between Asuna and Kirito is touching, the music is what you’d expect of Yuki Kajiura, which is to say awesome. The animation is good and aside from what I’ve made a point of complaining about the rest of it is at worst okay. It’s simple and fun, sometimes that’s all you want from a series.
All in all I’d give the series a 7/10, it’s not bad and at times it can be good and entertaining. Its just that taken as a whole its decent. It would be nice if it got a second season and/or an English dub.